Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
Index of Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
Blink! Think! Make Your Choice Use Your Voice Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
By Ira Chaleff on January 20, 2016 @ howtolearn.com
When you place your children in the care of other adults – day care providers, teachers, coaches, religious clerics, camp counselors – you trust they will be safe but you know you can’t be totally sure. When a supposedly trusted authority figure tells a child to do something wrong it is a confusing and potentially dangerous experience.You prepare your children to not get into cars with strangers or walk off with a stranger at the mall. How do you prepare them for the rare but complex situation when a legitimate authority figure tells them to do something they shouldn’t?
Many of us don’t. Let’s see how we might.
We already have a great example of how to do this from another safety activity. It is Stop, Drop and Roll. Most of were taught this at a very young age. If our clothes catch on fire, what do we do?
Stop, Drop and Roll.
This simple memorable saying has saved disfigurements and even deaths. Relatively few people have ever needed to use this. Yet they still remember it even decades later. Why?
A rhythmic rhyming phrase is memorable. When it is combined with simple practice our brains form a pattern for behavior that can activate when the right circumstances trigger it.
So let’s create a memorable saying we can teach and practice with our children about orders from authorities. The one I came up with is:
Blink, Think, Choice, Voice!
The full expression is Blink, Think, Make Your Choice, Use Your Voice. What is it telling your students or children to remember?
It is teaching them how to say “no” when saying “yes” would be harmful. This is known as Intelligent Disobedience. It is a critical skill both for safety and good citizenship. It is taught to guide dogs and service dogs. Surely we can teach it to children.
When individuals get an order that surprises them and seems wrong there is an initial startle response. This shuts off their reasoning and the social programming to obey authority can take over, putting them at risk of obeying when they should not.
This is what we want our children to remember when someone in authority (or, for that matter, a peer) tells them to do something that will be harmful to themselves or others:
BLINK: Register the shock. Pause. Blink a few times in disbelief. Take a few seconds to recover. Resist the social pressure to obey the authority figure.
THINK: What is at stake? Does the order make sense? Does it go against what you have been taught is right? Could obeying cause harm to you or another?
CHOICE: You always have a choice: obey, disobey, check with someone else, or offer a different option. Which choice seems right?
VOICE: Express your decision early and clearly. Don’t send a mixed message. If you decide “no”, say it so your meaning can’t be misunderstood. “No!” means “No!”
Explain these steps at an age appropriate level. Then model the steps. Here’s one example:
Have the child be the coach of your sports team. You’re the student receiving the order. The coach tells you to intentionally injure another player to get that player out of the game. Here’s what you do:
BLINK! Open your eyes wide and close them again quickly several times. Do this for a few seconds. You are taking control of the startle response.
THINK! Say what you’re thinking so the children can “hear” your thought process. “I’m thinking this isn’t right. We’re taught to play fair. We don’t hurt others on purpose.”
MAKE A CHOICE! Say the choice you make so the children can “hear” what you have concluded. “I’ve decided this is wrong and I am not going to obey.”
USE YOUR VOICE! Stand up straight, look the coach in the eye and say clearly “No! I won’t do that! I’m going to play fair.”
It is not difficult to devise simple Intelligent Disobedience role plays. Create age-appropriate scenarios involving different authority figures telling your children or students to do something wrong.
Next you want the children to practice doing this. Use the same scenario for the first few times until it is being done well. Then improvise another scenario, working up in difficulty and sensitivity.
Actual events that should have been met with Intelligent Disobedience have included children being told to help restrain other students with duct tape by teachers who have lost control of class behavior, students being given answers to standardized tests by teachers fearful of the consequences of poor test results and, most disturbingly, inappropriate sexual touching by camp counselors, clerics or older relatives.
Include in the role plays some well meaning orders that can still result in harm. For example, a crossing guard who doesn’t see a car coming around the corner and says it is okay to cross the street. You and other parents will have additional examples for role plays.
Why are rehearsals important? The shock of the moment shuts down cognitive functioning. Lacking prior rehearsal, there is no muscle memory to see the child through the dangerous event.
Imagine If a child’s clothes catch fire and she panics and starts to run. Without prior practice “Stop, drop and roll!” may not kick in as the correct response. The same is true with Intelligent Disobedience. Without some practice, the fight, flight or freeze syndrome may prevail instead.
Children can play both roles of the authority and of the child to keep it interesting and to develop further awareness of the fallibility of authority figures.
After they demonstrate competence in making the choice to say “no”, it is useful to do some role plays in which an authority gives an unusual order that should be obeyed. For example, if there is a shooter in the school and the teacher tells everyone to jump out of a first floor window.
It’s the same process: Blink. Think. Choice. Voice. In this case the choice is to obey and the voice is a silent or quiet “yes”. With older children you can introduce more complexity in which the choice is neither “yes” or “no” but offering a creative and safer alternative. I give examples in my book such as a role play for teenagers who have forgotten their key and are questioned by a police officer when they try climbing through a window to get into the house.
You can advocate for practice in school. It did not take a lot of time to introduce and practice “Stop, Drop and Roll”. It needn’t take a lot of time to practice Blink, Think, Choice, Voice.
But school lesson plans are already heavily loaded. More directly and more practically, you can create your own exercises for use in extra-curricular activities, religious training, etc. If you worry about sending your children on school or church travel programs or to summer camp, you can practice these simple role plays at home.
Blink and Think, make your Choice, use your Voice.
Not only will you keep your children safe. You will prepare them for the ethical decisions they will face as older teenagers, college students, working adults and citizens in an increasingly authority-oriented society.
For that matter, you yourself may need to practice this to use in your own life.
Blink, Think, Choice, Voice.
You are beginning to remember it already.
Teaching Initiative Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
Stephanie Howdle-Lang, Vice Principal Primary of Renaissance College in Hong Kong, pioneered the use of BlinkThinkChoiceVoice with over one hundred 10 year olds to great success.
She has since made presentations to educators from around the globe on how to introduce the concept and techniques of Intelligent Disobedience in their classrooms.
By explaining to parents that the purpose of Intelligent Disobedience helps keep their children safe, and enrolling their help with this at home. she got full support for this initiative from every parent. It was an inspiration to hear her describe the implementation of these ideas and techniques and to see the early successes this has produced.
Next is an example of the communication to parents that could be used.
Over the next few weeks in Year 5 we are going to be teaching your children a new skill. The skill is called “intelligent disobedience” and it is based on the work of Ira Chaleff. Here is a useful video which explains the idea of intelligent disobedience for children, and a little about what we will be teaching your children.
BLINK, THINK, VOICE, CHOICE:- //youtu.be/RdKPIK71SP8
The intention is to teach the children how to make sensible decisions about instructions that they are given by adults, particularly adults who they know. This might mean that your children question some of the instructions that you give them over the next few weeks. While the children are learning how to use intelligent disobedience, they may need your help and support. These are some of the things you might consider doing, if your child questions an instruction:
- In an emergency, say, “It’s an emergency so I can’t tell you why we need to do this now, but I will explain later.”
- Praise children when they do question you, but encourage them to think about the reasons behind instructions. This will help them to recognize unreasonable or unsafe requests. You can use phrases like these:
- “Why do you think I am telling you to do that?”
- “What do you think might happen if we don’t do that?”
- “Can you think of another way for us to…?”
We hope that this skill, which we will continue to develop throughout the year, will give the students valuable strategies for resisting peer pressure as well as knowing when to do the right thing and, importantly, how. Please do not hesitate to contact me with any questions.
Vice Principal Primary – Wellbeing
Handbook for Parents and Other Caregivers Resource and Tips for Teaching Children Intelligent Disobedience
The latest tool in teaching Intelligent Disobedience is a handbook for parents and caregivers to use with children. It provides an easy to remember technique to keep children safe if they are told to do something harmful.
Order your FREE copy.
It is simple to use and you can make copies for other adults or children in your household.